Top Jewelry Stores in New York

Finding a Jewelry Store in New York that is right for your needs can take time but is worth searching New York thoroughly for. Whether for a one time buy or to build a life time relationship it is important to find a jeweler you can trust. You want a reliable source for whatever your needs may be whether engagement rings, silver jewelry, gold jewelry, or diamond jewelry. So we have done the research for you, check out Eli’s top picks for New York.

If you know an amazing jewelry store in New York, let us know! Your opinion is valuable and we want to make sure everyone is able to find the best jewelry store for their needs without having to worry about the integrity. We turn to jewelry stores to commemorate some of the biggest moments of our life and show those we care about most how much they mean to us. Settling for a jeweler that isn’t the best isn’t an option when you consider the importance of those you love. That’s why if you have an experience with any of the jewelry stores listed in New York that isn’t exception, we want you to let us know!


Charisma Jewelers

Rochester, NY

Charisma Jewelers offers a variety of services which include special orders and custom jewelry design, jewelry repair including pearl and bead restringing, appraisals for insurance and estate purposes, jewelry cleaning and examination. They also buy gold, platinum and diamonds in all shapes sizes and colors.


Reeds Jenss

Buffalo, NY

Reeds Jewelers was opened in Niagara Falls in 1912. They have in-house designers and jewelers who craft styles that are only available at our stores. Jeffrey Zimmer, owner of Reeds Jewelers, personally travels the world to search for the finest diamonds and gemstones to ensure that the jewelry that are offered to the customers are of the best value.


Glennpeters Jewelers

Albany, NY

Glennpeters Jewelers Diamond Centre offers the high quality diamonds and jewelry. It was founded in 1950 by Nate Weiss. They specialize in diamonds and their store carries many different name brands of jewelry and diamonds. They are noted for their quality distinctive diamonds and jewelry and attentive service to our customers.


Diamond Cutters

Buffalo, NY

Established in 1984, Diamond Cutters now reaches throughout the United States. Their staff goes all over the world to purchase quality diamond rough and to select from the most current collections of jewelry designs. Recently, they were all over the media for cutting a 24-carat diamond and the press has marveled on its nearly flawless cut.


Wild Things

Buffalo, NY

Wild Things specializes in custom designed bridal jewelry and they carry a wide array of hand made artisan jewelry, as well as ceramics, prints and fibers. They are one of Buffalo's acclaimed locally owned businesses. Their store contains lavish bridal tiaras dripping with twinkling gemstones to bold, flashy necklaces donned with foreign coins.


Battisti Jewelers

Rochester, NY

Battisti Jewelers have been serving the greater Rochester, NY area for over 25 years offering a wide selection of retail jewelry items. They also offer repair services including to ring sizing's and soldering, chain and bracelet repairs, watch battery replacements and repairs, stone replacements and much more. They buy scrap and unwanted gold.


Mars Jewelry

Syracuse, NY

For over 40 years, Mars Jewelry has provided the Syracuse community with the best products and services in the area. They have a wide range of jewelry products from Loose Diamonds, Gold and Platinum to stylish Sterling Silver and Watches. They also offer services such as Watch repair, Jewelry repair on site.


M. Lemp Jewelers

Syracuse, NY

M. Lemp Jewelers was founded in 1890 by a German immigrant Michael Lemp. Presently, the have GIA trained diamond graders, a bench jeweler and a watchmaker on premise. They have internationally known jewelry and watch brands included in their inventory. Today, they continue to build on their eleven decade foundation and tradition of service, value and quality.


H Stern

New York, NY

H.Stern is recognized for constantly appearing in photographs of the world's most respected fashion magazines including Elle, Marie Claire, Vogue, and Harper's Bazaar. In addition, H. Stern Jewelry items are also known to be a favorite of national and international celebrities.


Heritage Jewelers

Rochester, NY

Heritage Jewelers has been open since 1969. They are committed in providing their customers with personal service and fine quality jewelry at affordable prices. They have a wide selection of unique innovative designer styles from unique talents in the jewelry business. They are an active member of the Gemological Institute of America, Jewelers Security Alliance and the Better Business Bureau.