Top Bakery in Tallahassee, FL
What a bakery is can mean different things depending on who you ask. Many of us are conjuring images of a Tallahassee, FL store filled with freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies, and cakes. While others are envisioning formal wedding cakes and bouquets of roses made out of gum paste or fondant. Both can apply and both require a high level of excellence. You want the best bakers in Tallahassee, FL working on your baked goods whether you need a pie for dessert, a baguette for dinner, or a wedding cake that your guests will remember 50 years from now. The wonderful bakeries in Tallahassee, FL can meet your needs and your tastes and we have the list to help you find the one that is perfect for you.
You can spend hours doing the research, sifting through reviews, comparing menu items, etc. Or you can use our handy list as a starting place in your quest for the best Tallahassee, FL bakery. Then, let us know which was your favorite, which had the best customer service, and which one went above and beyond for you. It may be the bakeries goal to have the best tasting, freshest baked goods around but you can never underestimate the importance of customer service. If you know of an amazing bakery that didn’t make the list, give them a shout out to us. It is possible we don’t know about them or they just need more feedback to make the list. Because that is what this list of Tallahassee, FL area bakeries is all about, delivering you a list of the best, and as always America Top 10 will never charge you to see our lists.
European Bakery & Cafe LLC
Naples, FL
European Bakery and Cafe is a small quirky style unique restaurant serving authentic fresh homemade meals, prepared by a husband/wife team that love to make everyone feel at home. Their meals are incredibly delicious, true home-style European meals prepared with only the freshest of ingredients and daily baked bread with an assortment of desserts.
The Power Plant Cafe Energized by Catalina Cafe
Tallahassee, FL
Power Plant, energized by local favorite Catalina Café, provides Tallahassee with a unique nook in the middle of Cascades Park perfect for unwinding, mingling, enjoying a killer cup of coffee, and eating gourmet sandwiches and sweets. You can expect to see all of Catalina’s signature items like their lattes, in-house roasted coffees, and delicious cuisines, while experiencing new items like all-natural juices.
Bruegger’s Bagels
Tallahassee, FL
Bruegger’s Bagels is recognized for being a fast casual bagel bakery, as well as a comfortable place to enjoy breakfast, lunch, or coffee breaks. The founders of Bruegger’s Bagels are also well-known for being the first to bring New York-style bagels to neighborhoods across America
Panera Bread
Tallahassee, FL
Panera Bread was established in 1981 with a goal of making great bread available to customers across the country. In addition to bread and pastries, Panera Bread also offers made-to-order sandwiches, tossed-to-order salads, and soup served in bread bowls.
Tasty Pastry Bakery
Tallahassee, FL
Tasty Pastry Bakery has been serving the city of Tallahassee since 1963 and they are currently offering a wide selection of cakes, cookies, breads, pies, and pastries. The Tasty Pastry team of bakers are also known to be using quality ingredients and the Cross family’s recipes.
Sweetie’s Delights Bakery
Valrico, FL
Sweetie’s Delights specializes in custom cake designs for all occasions. Each morning they stock their showcases with unique gourmet cupcakes, brownies, bars, cookies made with the highest quality ingredients right in their kitchen.
Catalina Café
Tallahassee, FL
Catalina Café is a family owned coffee shop and restaurant that opened its doors in 2010 and has been ignited by passion ever since. Using nothing but the finest ingredients in all of their coffees and cuisine is what sets them apart from the rest. They also serve made-from-scratch baked goods and unique made-to-order sandwiches for breakfast and lunch.
Treva’s Pastries & Fine Foods
Tallahassee, FL
Treva’s Pastries & Fine Foods, is a bistro-style pastry shop and fine foods store in Tallahassee. While they specialize in sweet treats, specialty cakes, pastries, and croissants they also use 100% natural ingredients to make delicious and savory sandwiches, salads, and soups.
Au Péché Mignon
Tallahassee, FL
With the combination of art and talent, their dedicated chefs present you with the most elegant collection of European confections available today. Operating from one location for over 20 years, they use only the finest natural ingredients selected from all over the world so they can bring that quality directly to you. They create the finest array of handmade pastries, cakes, macarons, cookies, sandwiches, breads, pies, drinks, and chocolates imaginable.
The Cake Shop Bakery
Tallahassee, FL
The Cake Shop Bakery, is said to be Tallahassee’s best bakery. Whether you are searching for a special birthday cake or simply looking for a sweet ending to an everyday meal, The Cake Shop offers something for everyone. This is a one of a kind bakery, where the aroma of home-style baking weakens even the strongest will.
Not find what your looking for? Try one of these other cities. Jacksonville, Miami, Orlando, Tampa.
