The Best Pizza in Indiana
Few foods speak to the American soul like pizza. Pizzas have become the most popular food in America with entire football fields eaten daily. In Indiana you can find a pizza places all over. You can make pizza however you like it. It doesn’t have to be unhealthy, maybe you use it to pile on the veggies for the kids. Or it can be a decadent special treat for yourself and family with all that oozy-gooey cheese you love.
There are also several different styles of pizza. The Chicago deep dish, famous for its thick crust topped with mounds of cheese and chunky tomato sauce is an excellent example. Other popular styles include Greek style, Neapolitan, Sicilian, and perhaps even Indiana style?
You may love only a specific style of pizza or you may love them all and enjoy savoring the differences of each. We focused on trying to choose not specific styles but a variety of styles that stood out in Indiana because we want you to be able to find something for every palette in your family.
Your input is welcome, are you a pizza aficionado? Have you tried every mom and pop pizza parlour in your state and know the best stops? When someone mentions a pizza party do you bring your pizza stone? Share with us your favorites in Indiana. We need your help to ensure America Top 10 has the most accurate lists possible.
If you are searching for a new place to try while out and about in Indiana then peruse the list below and we hope you enjoy it as much as we have undoubtedly done so. (This may be my favorite category to date, so hard having to taste test so many pizzas.)
Pizza King
Muncie, IN
Pizza King’s pizzas are known to be good to the very edge. Pizza King is also well-known to local diners for being previously voted as Muncie’s Finest Pizza in Muncie Star’s Reader’s Choice Poll. The restaurant has branches all over East Central Indiana as well.
Hungry Howie’s Pizza
Fort Wayne, IN
It starts with their dough, made fresh daily. Choose from their Original round, Deep Dish, or Thin Crust. Topped with their 100% real mozzarella cheese, add any of their quality toppings to create your favorite combination.
Smitty’s Italian Steakhouse
Evansville, IN
From authentic Italian cooking to a relaxed atmosphere, Smitty’s Italian Steakhouse is the perfect destination for a dinner date, lunch meeting or an after work bite to eat. They have a focused list of great wines and offer a full bar specializing in boutique spirits and craft beer. They represent handmade and farm fresh traditions.
Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders
Fort Wayne, IN
Mancino’s is a locally owned and operated family restaurant. They bake all of their bread from scratch each day and use only the best quality ingredients.
Steve’s Una Pizza
Evansville, IN
Steve’s Una Pizza isn’t your average pizza chain, their little shotgun style building has been home to the best Una style pizza for over 30 years. Their dough is made fresh daily, rolled thin, and cut to your preferred sizing. They offer the best high quality meats and veggies. Their beef and pork are freshly ground daily from the Ye Old Fashioned Butcher Shop. Their famous sausage is seasoned here in the shop with their own special recipe.
Starlite Pizza
South Bend, IN
At Starlite Pizza, they are well known for their homemade thin crust pizza and sweet tomato sauce. The recipe has changed little over the years, still providing a unique pizza to the South Bend area. The sauce and pizza dough are family recipes that use 100% mozzarella cheese.
South Of Chicago Pizza
Indianapolis, IN
South of Chicago Pizza & Beef features traditional-style Chicago pizza and local craft beers. They use fresh ingredients and bring Chicago-style pizza and Italian beef sandwiches to Indianapolis, including hand-made crusts and meatballs, fresh Italian sausage delivered from Chicago’s best markets and Gonnella French Bread shipped from Chicago daily.
Antonio’s Restaurant
Elkhart, IN
If you are looking for authentic Italian cuisine and great service, you have come to the right place. At Antonio’s Italian Ristorante they will give you the attention and great food you have come to expect and enjoy. Antonio’s Italian Ristorante has been located in Elkhart since 1979.
Heady’s Pizza
Evansville, IN
At Heady’s Pizza they believe their customers deserve to experience what truly good Italian food is. From their fresh pastas to their made to order pizzas, subs, and appetizers, they feel everyone will find their own “favorite” Heady’s menu item. They take pride in delivering the highest level of quality to each and every customer.
Tony Sacco’s Coal Oven Pizza
Granger , IN
The Tony Sacco’s Coal Oven Pizza team uses a custom-built, 1000 degree anthracite coal-burning oven to prepare their pizza. In addition, they also use sauce that is made from scratch and mozzarella that is the best available kind as well.