America Top 10

  • Home
  • Find A Top 10 List
  • News & Information
  • Our History
  • Contact Us
Home / America / New Jersey / Paterson / Best Pizza

The Best Pizza in Paterson, NJ

Few foods speak to the American soul like pizza. Pizzas have become the most popular food in America with entire football fields eaten daily. In Paterson, NJ you can find a pizza places all over. You can make pizza however you like it. It doesn’t have to be unhealthy, maybe you use it to pile on the veggies for the kids. Or it can be a decadent special treat for yourself and family with all that oozy-gooey cheese you love.

There are also several different styles of pizza. The Chicago deep dish, famous for its thick crust topped with mounds of cheese and chunky tomato sauce is an excellent example. Other popular styles include Greek style, Neapolitan, Sicilian, and perhaps even Paterson, NJ style?

You may love only a specific style of pizza or you may love them all and enjoy savoring the differences of each. We focused on trying to choose not specific styles but a variety of styles that stood out in Paterson, NJ because we want you to be able to find something for every palette in your family.

Your input is welcome, are you a pizza aficionado? Have you tried every mom and pop pizza parlour in your state and know the best stops? When someone mentions a pizza party do you bring your pizza stone? Share with us your favorites in Paterson, NJ. We need your help to ensure America Top 10 has the most accurate lists possible.

If you are searching for a new place to try while out and about in Paterson, NJ then peruse the list below and we hope you enjoy it as much as we have undoubtedly done so. (This may be my favorite category to date, so hard having to taste test so many pizzas.)

Lefty’s Restaurant and Pizzeria

Paterson, NJ

Lefty’s Restaurant & Pizzeria welcomes you and your family to enjoy their delicious pizza, salads, burgers, desserts and more, and you can even create your own pasta. At Lefty’s, they continually strives to bring you world-class pizza and Italian dishes in an enjoyable & friendly atmosphere. They offer a wide range of specialty pizzas, pastas, calzones & Stromboli’s, and other flavorful creations that will leave you asking for more.

Piccolo’s Pizza & Liquors

Paterson, NJ

Piccolo’s Pizza was established in 1972 and has been the Paterson area’s #1 Pizzeria for over 35 years. With a growing menu of gourmet items, Piccolo’s Pizza continues to serve the best home-made Italian food in Northern NJ.

Mico’s Pizzeria

Fair Lawn, NJ

Mico’s Pizzeria works hard to serve the best Italian cuisine there is. At Mico’s, they are passionate about food. Their flavorful recipes will excite your taste buds and make you feel right at home. They use only the finest ingredients money can buy in everything they make. Whether you are hungry for a filling sub, a crisp salad, a hearty pasta dinner, or pizza fresh from the oven, they’ve got just what your looking for.

Pizza City

Paterson, NJ

Pizza City, has the biggest slice around, there is no choice but them. They know there are many choices out there, the management and staff of Pizza City extend their sincere appreciation for your support and patronage. Their goal is to always provide you with a truly satisfying eating experience.

Ray’s House of the Famous Grandma’s Pizza

Fair Lawn, NJ

Ray’s House of the Famous Grandma’s Pizza, has been said to be the best pizza in Fairlawn. They do it all, pizza, pasta, salad, wings, subs, and more.

Nauna’s Bella Casa Ristorante

Montclair, NJ

Nauna’s Bella Casa Ristorante specializes in serving a broad range of Italian food, from pizzas, pastas, and soups, to dishes with fish, meat, and vegetables. The restaurant also claims to be the area’s best in home-made Italian cuisine.

Tommys Taste of Italy

West Paterson, NJ

Tommy’s Taste of Italy is a family-run Italian Pork Store/deli/pizzeria in Woodland Park, and they are proud to serve authentic Italian cuisine, products, deli meats, domestic and imported cheese, specialty heros, salads and yes, pizza too.

Twisted Elm

Elmwood Park, NJ

Twisted Elm is a New American restaurant in Elmwood Park, and is one of the first Gastropubs to have opened in the North Jersey area in 2011. At Twisted Elm, you will definitely enjoy everything they are ready to offer.

Brother Bruno’s Pizza

Wayne, NJ

Serving the Wayne area since 1976, Brother Bruno Pizza is Wayne’s oldest family owned and operated pizzeria. They offer fresh made bagels and a full breakfast of egg platters, pancakes, breakfast sandwiches and wraps, as well as an expanded menu to include healthier breakfast, lunch and dinner options. They use the freshest & finest ingredients able to consistently serve you the best Pizza, Subs, pasta and more.

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Fair Lawn, NJ

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza offers great tasting pizzas throughout the area. In addition to pizza, customers enjoy a variety of “Italian Soul Food” items, including Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings and Eggplant Marino.

Not find what your looking for? Try one of these other cities. Edison, Elizabeth, Jersey City, Newark.

Random Fact

It is estimated that about 38% of Americans prefer vegetable toppings on their pizzas.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related Information

<?php echo How to Make Mozzarella; ?>

How to Make Mozzarella

May 3, 2019 By Elizabeth

<?php echo Easy Homemade Pizza Sauce; ?>

Easy Homemade Pizza Sauce

December 14, 2018 By Elizabeth

<?php echo What Types of Pizza Crust are There?; ?>

What Types of Pizza Crust are There?

October 8, 2018 By Elizabeth

What makes the brick oven pizza different?

June 3, 2017 By Elizabeth

<?php echo Pepperoni Pizza Wrap Recipe; ?>

Pepperoni Pizza Wrap Recipe

April 7, 2017 By Elizabeth

About America Top 10

It is all thanks to you! We never envisioned when America Top 10 launched way back in 2011 that we would come this far this fast. And it is all thanks to you. You have made America Top 10 the successful resource it is for tens of thousands of people like you every single day.

And we cherish all the wise advice, suggestions, questions, and comments you send us every day even if we do not get a chance to get back with every single one. We take pride in helping people find trustworthy sources in their local areas and we hope to keep doing this for a very long time.

Recent Articles

  • Electricians & EV Charging
  • Travel Agents can Save You Money
  • Tips for Hiring a Handyman
  • How a CPA Can Help Your Small Business
  • Taekwondo helps Develop Discipline

Search

Copyright © 2025 America Top 10. All Rights Reserved.