Top Bakery in New York
What a bakery is can mean different things depending on who you ask. Many of us are conjuring images of a New York store filled with freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies, and cakes. While others are envisioning formal wedding cakes and bouquets of roses made out of gum paste or fondant. Both can apply and both require a high level of excellence. You want the best bakers in New York working on your baked goods whether you need a pie for dessert, a baguette for dinner, or a wedding cake that your guests will remember 50 years from now. The wonderful bakeries in New York can meet your needs and your tastes and we have the list to help you find the one that is perfect for you.
You can spend hours doing the research, sifting through reviews, comparing menu items, etc. Or you can use our handy list as a starting place in your quest for the best New York bakery. Then, let us know which was your favorite, which had the best customer service, and which one went above and beyond for you. It may be the bakeries goal to have the best tasting, freshest baked goods around but you can never underestimate the importance of customer service. If you know of an amazing bakery that didn’t make the list, give them a shout out to us. It is possible we don’t know about them or they just need more feedback to make the list. Because that is what this list of New York area bakeries is all about, delivering you a list of the best, and as always America Top 10 will never charge you to see our lists.
Savoia Pastry
Rochester, NY
Savoia Pastry has been specializing in baking fresh Italian cookies, pastries, desserts, wedding cakes, bread, and other types of specialty cakes since its inception in 1929. Tea cookies are also known to be the single most popular item sold at Savoia’s to date.
Billy’s Bakery
New York, NY
Billy’s Bakery was established in 2003 with a goal of providing customers with classic American baked goods in a warm and friendly atmosphere. They are also known to be currently baking all of their products from scratch while also using the finest ingredients available.
Ohlson’s Bakery & Cafe
Buffalo, NY
Ohlson’s Bakery & Cafe, is a quaint European bakery with a family history of baking. Their recipes are passed down from generations and they are so lucky to share them with you.
Jackson’s Bakery
Rochester, NY
Jackson’s Bakery, has been 67 years in the making. They specializes in butter cookies, breads, a variety of pastries and cakes.
Gino’s Italian Bakery
Buffalo, NY
Gino’s Italian Bakery has been serving North Buffalo and the surrounding communities for more than thirty years. Whether your favorite Italian desserts are cookies, cartocci, pasticiotti, cannolis or cassata cake, Gino’s Bakery is the place to go. The hope is that with each bite of a Gino’s dessert you will be treated to a little taste of “old world” Italy!
Gruttadauria
Rochester, NY
Gruttadauria offers over 50 different varieties of cookies. In addition, they are proud of their products that are baked with the same ingredients, care, and attention that has been handed down through four generations of family bakers. Gruttadauria Bakery has been in business since 1914.
Mario’s Bakery
North Syracuse, NY
Mario’s Bakery, is a full-line bakery catering to your every occasion. They will gladly accept special orders for baked goods including holiday and special occasion cakes, cookies, pastries and breads.
Genesee Bakery & Deli
Rochester, NY
Genesee Bakery & Deli can customize any of the following: wedding or occasion cakes, pastry and sandwich trays, cookie trays, pies, pastries, as well as breads and rolls. Genesee Bakery & Deli has been owned and operated by the Fiorito family since 1988.
Martusciello’s
Rochester, NY
Martusciello’s is famous for its offered breads and rolls, calzones, hot and cold subs, pizza, cookies, pies, fresh filled cannoli’s, and pastries. Martusciello’s Bakery Inc’s roots began in the town of Pignataro Maggiore in Italy by Gaetano Martusciello.
Caramici’s Bakery
Buffalo, NY
Caramici’s offers an Italian home-style bakery featuring desserts, wedding cakes, and cakes for all occasions. For those with pure food indulgence in mind, come next door and sate your desires with theeir ever changing internationally and seasonally inspired small plates.