America Top 10

  • Home
  • Find A Top 10 List
  • News & Information
  • Our History
  • Contact Us
Home / America / Ohio / Columbus / Insurance Agents

Top Insurance Agents in Columbus, OH

Insurance agents are a necessity whether for automotive or home. Here, we have compiled a list of the best insurance brokers in Columbus, OH. Finding an insurance agent that you really enjoy and you can ensure has your best interests in mind can be difficult.

We all need the comfort and reassurance that our property is being properly protected. There is enough in life to worry about as it is, without having to worry if some devastating event is going to leave you high and dry. So, give our insurance agents in Columbus, OH a call and find the one that is the best fit for you.

We highly recommend giving each a thorough interview, as this aspect of your life is far too important to leave to chance. So, whether you are looking for home, renter, or automotive coverage check out our listings in the Columbus, OH area.

Don’t forget that it is your input that helps us rank these insurance agents. So please, if you have an amazing or terrible experience with an insurance broker in the Columbus, OH area, let us know! Your opinion and experiences are invaluable to us. And we hope that our lists can help take just a little bit of stress off of your undoubtedly busy day.

Bob Erlanger

Columbus, OH

Bob joined Allstate in 2008 because of Allstate’s reputation as an industry leader in customer service and claims. He is proud to be a part of a storied tradition of helping to protect the things that matter most to people and giving back to the community. The Erlanger Agency is an award-winning agency with a team of licensed insurance professionals who specialize in home, auto and life insurance.

Matt Rappolt

Columbus, OH

Matt joined Ray Insurance in 2000 and specializes in commercial insurance. He takes pride in working to tailor specialized programs to fit each clients specific insurance needs.

Amie Kim

Columbus, OH

Amie has been an agent with State Farm for over 10 years. Their agency creates custom quotes that will suit your specific needs, and we will take the time to explain your policy with you (in layman’s terms).

Angela Freeman

Columbus, OH

Angie started her insurance career in 1992 as a customer service representative in the Access Insurance Agency. She was fully licensed in property and casualty insurance in 1996. Access Insurance was purchased by Augustine Insurance Agency in 2001 and Angie has been with the agency ever since. Her duties include customer service and sales of auto, home, boat and recreational vehicles.

Carla Lytle

Columbus, OH

Carla, having hailed from The Ohio State University in 1980, joined Augustine Insurance in 2000. She has been fully licensed in property and casualty insurance since 2002. Her primary duties include sales and service of auto, home, boat and recreational vehicles. She is ready and waiting to assist you with all of your insurance needs.

Richard Schooley, AAI, AIS

Groveport, OH

Rich is the Agency Principal of Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC as of June 1, 2011. He formerly owned and operated The Schooley Insurance Agency. Rich is a member of the Southeastern Franklin County Chamber of Commerce. He is also a member of Professional Independent Insurance Agents Association of Ohio. He is an Accredited Advisor in Insurance and holds an Associate in Insurance Services. His goal is to give sound insurance advice at an affordable cost.

Matt Clegg

Columbus, OH

Matt was born and raised in central Ohio. He has been serving this area as your GEICO Insurance Agent since 2005.

Fred Lockwood, LUTCF

Columbus, OH

Fred joined the firm in 2006 by merging his agency C&I Insurance of Worthington with the Ray Agency. Fred brings more than 20 years of insurance experience and specializes in Health Insurance and Employee Benefits.

Norm Risoya, LUTCF

Columbus, OH

As a Personal Financial Representative in Columbus, Norm looks forward to helping families like yours protect the things that are important, your family, home, car and more. He can also help you prepare a strategy to achieve your financial goals.

Robert Smith Jr.

Columbus, OH

When it comes to selecting an insurance agency, what’s most important to you? Good reputation? Integrity and reliability? A leading knowledge in the insurance industry? Affordable, effective coverage that fits your needs? You’ll receive all of these things from our experienced team of licensed professionals who are committed to satisfying your financial protection needs. Robert and his team, has been a top-ranking Nationwide agency for more than 30 years, and they are one of the largest multi-line insurance agencies in central Ohio.

Not find what your looking for? Try one of these other cities. Cincinnati, Cleveland, Dayton, Toledo.

Random Fact

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related Information

<?php echo Should you take a Driver Safety Course?; ?>

Should you take a Driver Safety Course?

November 28, 2018 By Eric Thoroughgood

<?php echo How to choose the best insurance company for your home?; ?>

How to choose the best insurance company for your home?

September 24, 2018 By Elizabeth

About America Top 10

It is all thanks to you! We never envisioned when America Top 10 launched way back in 2011 that we would come this far this fast. And it is all thanks to you. You have made America Top 10 the successful resource it is for tens of thousands of people like you every single day.

And we cherish all the wise advice, suggestions, questions, and comments you send us every day even if we do not get a chance to get back with every single one. We take pride in helping people find trustworthy sources in their local areas and we hope to keep doing this for a very long time.

Recent Articles

  • Electricians & EV Charging
  • Travel Agents can Save You Money
  • Tips for Hiring a Handyman
  • How a CPA Can Help Your Small Business
  • Taekwondo helps Develop Discipline

Search

Copyright © 2025 America Top 10. All Rights Reserved.