America Top 10

  • Home
  • Find A Top 10 List
  • News & Information
  • Our History
  • Contact Us
Home / America / Ohio / Insurance Agents

Top Insurance Agents in Ohio

Insurance agents are a necessity whether for automotive or home. Here, we have compiled a list of the best insurance brokers in Ohio. Finding an insurance agent that you really enjoy and you can ensure has your best interests in mind can be difficult.

We all need the comfort and reassurance that our property is being properly protected. There is enough in life to worry about as it is, without having to worry if some devastating event is going to leave you high and dry. So, give our insurance agents in Ohio a call and find the one that is the best fit for you.

We highly recommend giving each a thorough interview, as this aspect of your life is far too important to leave to chance. So, whether you are looking for home, renter, or automotive coverage check out our listings in the Ohio area.

Don’t forget that it is your input that helps us rank these insurance agents. So please, if you have an amazing or terrible experience with an insurance broker in the Ohio area, let us know! Your opinion and experiences are invaluable to us. And we hope that our lists can help take just a little bit of stress off of your undoubtedly busy day.

Barbara Hall

CINCINNATI, OH

As your American Family Insurance agent, Barbara can offer you dependable auto, home, business, health and life insurance, as well as other insurance products.

James Proffitt

Dayton, OH

James has the knowledge and experience to help you better understand your coverage options, whether that’s auto, home, renters, business insurance and more.

Jennifer Shepler

Toledo, OH

Jennifer started with the agency in March of 2015 and became a licensed agent in 2016. Her nine years of experience in the fire and water restoration industry has shown Jennifer the importance of having insurance.

Ann Joyce

Dayton, OH

Ann began her insurance career with the agency in 1991, becoming a licensed agent shortly after. She is people-oriented and handles most of the personal accounts as well as all billing matters.

Tammy Gresko

Toledo, OH

Tammy began her working career at the young age of nine when her family opened a small grocery store in Sylvania,  Tammy was able to utilize her skills and experience during her fifteen-year career in the banking industry. She joined the Fuller and Sons Insurance team in 2012.

Richard S. Pilat, CIC

Parma, OH

Richard obtained his insurance license in 1985, and graduated from Kent State University with a Bachelor of Business Administration degree in Finance in 1987. Upon graduation, he joined the agency that was founded by his father, Stephen Pilat. Rich completed his Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation in 1992.

Valerie Carr

Cincinnati, OH

Valerie was born with a personality that led her to easily choose to become an Insurance Sales Agent for the past 30 yrs. She is outgoing, enjoys meeting new people and can mix professionalism and fun together. She has a wide range of insurance knowledge but likes to specialize in the Real Estate industry. If you own or manage property, she is your go to person.

Nicholas Chupp

Toledo, OH

As a life long resident of Toledo, he is proud to be your local Farmers agent. Nicholas helps customers like you identify the insurance coverage that best fits your needs. This process is straightforward and personalized to help make you smarter about insurance.

Richard Schooley, AAI, AIS

Groveport, OH

Rich is the Agency Principal of Keystone Insurance Agency, LLC as of June 1, 2011. He formerly owned and operated The Schooley Insurance Agency. Rich is a member of the Southeastern Franklin County Chamber of Commerce. He is also a member of Professional Independent Insurance Agents Association of Ohio. He is an Accredited Advisor in Insurance and holds an Associate in Insurance Services. His goal is to give sound insurance advice at an affordable cost.

Marianne Geiger

Cincinnati, OH

As an Allstate Agent in Cincinnati, Marianne knows many local families. Her knowledge and understanding of the people in the community helps her provide customers with an outstanding level of service. She is proud to offer Allstate products, because they stand by their service.

Random Fact

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related Information

<?php echo Should you take a Driver Safety Course?; ?>

Should you take a Driver Safety Course?

November 28, 2018 By Eric Thoroughgood

<?php echo How to choose the best insurance company for your home?; ?>

How to choose the best insurance company for your home?

September 24, 2018 By Elizabeth

About America Top 10

It is all thanks to you! We never envisioned when America Top 10 launched way back in 2011 that we would come this far this fast. And it is all thanks to you. You have made America Top 10 the successful resource it is for tens of thousands of people like you every single day.

And we cherish all the wise advice, suggestions, questions, and comments you send us every day even if we do not get a chance to get back with every single one. We take pride in helping people find trustworthy sources in their local areas and we hope to keep doing this for a very long time.

Recent Articles

  • Electricians & EV Charging
  • Travel Agents can Save You Money
  • Tips for Hiring a Handyman
  • How a CPA Can Help Your Small Business
  • Taekwondo helps Develop Discipline

Search

Copyright © 2026 America Top 10. All Rights Reserved.