America Top 10

  • Home
  • Find A Top 10 List
  • News & Information
  • Our History
  • Contact Us
Home / America / Wisconsin / Madison / Insurance Agents

Top Insurance Agents in Madison, WI

Insurance agents are a necessity whether for automotive or home. Here, we have compiled a list of the best insurance brokers in Madison, WI. Finding an insurance agent that you really enjoy and you can ensure has your best interests in mind can be difficult.

We all need the comfort and reassurance that our property is being properly protected. There is enough in life to worry about as it is, without having to worry if some devastating event is going to leave you high and dry. So, give our insurance agents in Madison, WI a call and find the one that is the best fit for you.

We highly recommend giving each a thorough interview, as this aspect of your life is far too important to leave to chance. So, whether you are looking for home, renter, or automotive coverage check out our listings in the Madison, WI area.

Don’t forget that it is your input that helps us rank these insurance agents. So please, if you have an amazing or terrible experience with an insurance broker in the Madison, WI area, let us know! Your opinion and experiences are invaluable to us. And we hope that our lists can help take just a little bit of stress off of your undoubtedly busy day.

Brian Schroeder

Madison, WI

Brian has been serving Wisconsin as your GEICO Insurance Agent since 2005. For over 20 years, he worked in the financial industry giving personal investment advice, which gave him a great sense of how to help you find the most discounts on your insurance.

Ryan Waite

Madison, WI

A native of Madison, Ryan graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Madison with a degree in Psychology and minors in Business and Criminal Justice. He started his career as a retirement plan manager at Kelly Financial in Madison. Ryan joined Neckerman Insurance Services in 2010, specializing in business and personal insurance. He has earned the Certified Risk Manager (CRM) and Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designations which are nationally recognized as important credentials for insurance agents, benefiting his agency and clients. He is now pursuing the new Certified Personal Risk Manager (CPRM) designation to further serve his high net worth personal insurance clients.

Nathan Huset

Madison, WI

Nate, originally from Verona, attended the University of Wisconsin-Madison and graduated with a degree in International Economics. He joined Neckerman Insurance Services in 2003 and specializes in commercial insurance. He has earned the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation which means you have the knowledge, personal dedication and expertise to succeed in the ever-changing and demanding insurance profession.

Dennis Gullickson, LUTCF

Madison, WI

Dennis joined Affiliated Insurance Agencies in 2011. He previously had his own insurance agency with Rural Mutual Insurance for 21 years. Dennis believes in getting to know his clients personally, building long term relationships based on trust and knowledge. Dennis works with personal and commercial insurance products, and also enjoys getting out into the country and working with farms.

Peter Arttus

Madison, WI

Born and raised in Wisconsin, Peter is proud to serve the Madison area as your local Farmers agent. With almost 40 years in the insurance industry, he has the knowledge and experience to help you better understand your coverage options.

David Scher

MADISON, WI

David is a graduate from UW-Madison, with a degree in Risk Management. David is a third generation of American Family agents. His grandfather founded the home office agency ‘Wittwer, Kalbskopf and Webster’ in 1933. David’s dad, Chuck Webster, was an agent from 1954 to 1998.

Nick Eifert

Middleton, WI

Nick has been with the agency since June 2003, and he has excelled in serving his clients with fast and efficient service.

Paul Herrick

Madison, WI

As a graduate of UW Madison in 2006, Paul started out his insurance career on the company side as a specialty lines underwriter for NSI – A Division of West Bend. After three years of gaining valuable insurance experience and knowledge, Paul chose to expand his insurance career and become an independent insurance agent. As an agent with Affiliated Insurance, Paul’s had the opportunity to build long and lasting relationships with his clients by understanding and protecting their insurance needs.

Monty Homewood

Madison, WI

Monty is the founder and owner of Homewood Insurance Agency. Monty started his insurance career in 1989 as a captive agent working for a nationally recognized insurance company. He later joined the Couri Insurance Group as an independent insurance agent, forming the Homewood Insurance Agency. Monty is a member of the Wisconsin Professional Insurance Agents.

Kyle Fetters

Madison, WI

Kyle attended the University of Mississippi where he obtained a Broadcast Journalism degree. Kyle joined the  sales team at Neckerman Insurance Services in July of 2016 and hit the ground running. He is licensed in Property & Casualty and Life & Health insurance and will continue to grow his knowledge by working toward his CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) designation.

Not find what your looking for? Try one of these other cities. Appleton, Green Bay, Milwaukee.

Random Fact

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related Information

<?php echo Should you take a Driver Safety Course?; ?>

Should you take a Driver Safety Course?

November 28, 2018 By Eric Thoroughgood

<?php echo How to choose the best insurance company for your home?; ?>

How to choose the best insurance company for your home?

September 24, 2018 By Elizabeth

About America Top 10

It is all thanks to you! We never envisioned when America Top 10 launched way back in 2011 that we would come this far this fast. And it is all thanks to you. You have made America Top 10 the successful resource it is for tens of thousands of people like you every single day.

And we cherish all the wise advice, suggestions, questions, and comments you send us every day even if we do not get a chance to get back with every single one. We take pride in helping people find trustworthy sources in their local areas and we hope to keep doing this for a very long time.

Recent Articles

  • Electricians & EV Charging
  • Travel Agents can Save You Money
  • Tips for Hiring a Handyman
  • How a CPA Can Help Your Small Business
  • Taekwondo helps Develop Discipline

Search

Copyright © 2025 America Top 10. All Rights Reserved.