The Best Pizza in Wisconsin
Few foods speak to the American soul like pizza. Pizzas have become the most popular food in America with entire football fields eaten daily. In Wisconsin you can find a pizza places all over. You can make pizza however you like it. It doesn’t have to be unhealthy, maybe you use it to pile on the veggies for the kids. Or it can be a decadent special treat for yourself and family with all that oozy-gooey cheese you love.
There are also several different styles of pizza. The Chicago deep dish, famous for its thick crust topped with mounds of cheese and chunky tomato sauce is an excellent example. Other popular styles include Greek style, Neapolitan, Sicilian, and perhaps even Wisconsin style?
You may love only a specific style of pizza or you may love them all and enjoy savoring the differences of each. We focused on trying to choose not specific styles but a variety of styles that stood out in Wisconsin because we want you to be able to find something for every palette in your family.
Your input is welcome, are you a pizza aficionado? Have you tried every mom and pop pizza parlour in your state and know the best stops? When someone mentions a pizza party do you bring your pizza stone? Share with us your favorites in Wisconsin. We need your help to ensure America Top 10 has the most accurate lists possible.
If you are searching for a new place to try while out and about in Wisconsin then peruse the list below and we hope you enjoy it as much as we have undoubtedly done so. (This may be my favorite category to date, so hard having to taste test so many pizzas.)
Il Ritrovo
Sheboygan, WI
Il Ritrovo specializes mainly in true Neopolitan pizzas and other authentic Italian cuisine. Il Ritrovo is also widely recognized for its extensive wine selection, as well as its various cocktails and beers. They have been in business since 2000.
‘zza Odyssey Pizzeria
Appleton, WI
‘zza Odyssey Pizzeria & Pub is a pizza restaurant that offers a unique and satisfying pizza. Choose from a variety of signature pizzas, or select a salad, wings or a sandwich. They also have a variety of appetizer and dessert options to complement your meal.
Lisa’s Fine Foods
Milwaukee, WI
Dine in, take it out, or have the best pizza around delivered to your home from Lisa’s Fine Foods. They are a family-owned, 41-year-old pizza parlor and have an established reputation for quality pizza. Their quality pizzas are made fresh daily from the finest ingredients, and their friendly staff has a niche for getting your pizza done right and delivered to your table piping hot.
Pizza Brutta
Madison, WI
Pizza Brutta prides itself in its fresh mozzarella is made from Wisconsin curd, which is a prominent ingredient in their pizzas. They are also known for their environmental consciousness as they utilize wood from sustainable woodsman and partner with local and organic suppliers as well.
Novanta
Madison, WI
Novanta refers to the ever-important ninety seconds that their authentic Neapolitan pizzas bake in their wood-burning oven before they are served hot and fresh to you. They offer only the finest and the freshest ingredients and toppings, including house-made mozzarella cheese from their mozzarella bar. Novanta is pleased to offer guests authentic Neapolitan pizzas, panini, insalate, dolci, and a fine assortment of beverages. They also feature a mozzarella bar with a selection of cheeses that are both house-made and imported from Italy.
Homerun Pizza
Appleton, WI
Home Run Pizza offers quality pizzas made from scratch with the finest ingredients available. They start with their crust, which is home made by hand daily, then add a sauce that is custom flavored with herbs and spices to enhance their pizza. Then they add the highest quality pizza toppings available including top of the line mozzarella cheese they grate fresh daily from block form.
Grazies Italian Grill
Green Bay, WI
Grazies offers signature recipes customer-tested and customer-approved over the years. With no heat lamps or microwaves, and most everything you can think of “Made Fresh from Scratch” with better ingredients for a better you. They offer family, friends, and loved ones a money-well-spent-experience, guaranteed.
Parma
Appleton, WI
Their partnerships with local farms ensure every dish you dive into will be fresh and delicious. Parma values the social importance of good food in good company. When you gather at Parma, you can be sure your food has been carefully handcrafted for taste, presentation, and with the desire to keep you coming back.
Stucs Pizza
Appleton, WI
Stuc’s Pizza has offered a world-class pizza, made from scratch, for over 20 years. Their family sourced recipes are unique and sure to please. Nutrition isn’t usually associated with pizza but their product is made with real food and quality fresh ingredients.
Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria and Pub
Neenah, WI
Cranky Pat’s Pizzeria and Pub was established over 50 years ago by two young men who were pizza lovers. Now, in addition to serving pizza, they also have other Italian specialties, served in all four different locations, each with their own unique character.
